| ||
Random quote: If you want your children to be intelligent, read them fairy tales. If you want them to be more intelligent, read them more fairy tales. - Albert Einstein - (Added by: Engelbrecht) |
The basis for ratings Moderators: Admin Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page] | View previous thread :: View next thread |
Web Site Feedback -> Comments & Suggestions | Message format |
dh65 |
| ||
New User Posts: 3 Location: New York, NY | Do members have any sort of working rules of thumb about how to assign numbers and what the numbers mean to them? In other words, when would you give a book a 7 as opposed to an 8, for example? Or (even tougher, probably) a 3 as opposed to a 4? A thumbs-up-or-thumbs-down scale is obvious. An A-B-C-D-F system is a bit less obvious but reasonably well understood, and it has the virtue of allowing gradations of success but not of failure. But I just get a bit lost with a 10-point scale. So I'm just wondering how other people apply the scale. Sorry if this seems obsessive, but I have a hunch that I'm not the only nerd member here. DH65 | ||
Rhondak101 |
| ||
Uber User Posts: 770 Location: SC, USA | dh65, This is an interesting question. You've made me think about how I've been rating. I've realized that I really do use a 5 point scale. As a teacher, I think in an A through F scale. A book I feel is average is a 7. An okay book with a glaring defect is 6. I think I rarely rank below 5 or F. I seem to have lots of 8s. I have ranked one book a 3. I thought it was sophomoric and repetitive, and needed to be cut by about 250 pages. I only kept reading it because it was nominated for a big award, which it won. I was determined to finish it, but I should have stopped at page 100. I think my 3 represents my anger that I didn't listen to my gut and stop reading : ) | ||
Scott Laz |
| ||
Uber User Posts: 263 Location: Gunnison, Colorado | Rhonda's take sounds pretty similar to mine. I'm also a teacher, and I'm probably subject to the influence of grade inflation! I'd probably have an easier time with a 5-point scale. I also tend to think of an average book as around 7, but that's consistent with vetting books ahead of time and sticking with generally well-regarded books, or authors I especially like. I don't read much that is really "average," in other words, so I don't have a problem with an average rating being higher than average :-) As someone especially interested in the history of the genre, I tend to add a point for historical importance/influence sometimes. When read in historical context, some books can seem a lot more impressive than they otherwise would. Another thing you quickly learn from teaching is that your relative standards can change. I always go back and look at the first few papers I graded after finishing the last one, as I might start out grading more harshly but "ease up" as I see more and more students having similar difficulties (or it can also work the other way around). The point there is that, after you've rated quite a few, you might want to look back over your list and consider whether the rankings are consistent. Do you really like every "8" better than every "7", or are there discrepancies to correct? (Yeah, it's a little obsessive, but if it's worth doing, it's worth thinking about a little...) Edited by Scott Laz 2012-02-17 1:30 PM | ||
dh65 |
| ||
New User Posts: 3 Location: New York, NY | I dropped out of a Ph.D. program but not before grading hundreds of student papers and exams, so I too find a scale of A to F relatively easy to apply. That is probably because in grading students' work I developed a set of qualitative descriptions for each grade level, since qualitative assessments come much more naturally to me than do quantitative ones. So I've come up with a rubric which I've found useful in rating books here: 10=perfect or close enough 9=nearly perfect, with very limited but identifiable room for improvement 8=great, with easily forgiven but clear flaws that are decisively eclipsed by the virtues and successes 7=good, worth reading but not thrilling 6=alright, better than nothing 5=neutral, forgettable 4=boring 3=annoying 2=insulting 1=unreadable | ||
Jump to page : 1 Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page] |
Search this forum Printer friendly version E-mail a link to this thread |
Books
BOOK AWARDS
Hugo Award
Nebula Award
BSFA Award
Mythopoeic Award
Locus SF Award
Locus Fantasy Award
Locus FN Award
Locus YA Award
Locus Horror Award
August Derleth Award
Robert Holdstock Award
Campbell Award
World Fantasy Award
Prometheus Award
Aurora Award
PKD Award
Clarke Award
Stoker Award
Otherwise Award
Aurealis SF Award
Aurealis Fantasy Award
Aurealis Horror Award
Andre Norton Award
Shirley Jackson Award
Red Tentacle Award
Golden Tentacle Award
Legend Award
Morningstar Award
Nommo Award
BOOK LISTS
Classics of SF
SF Mistressworks
Guardian: The Best SF/F
NPR: Top 100 SF/F
Pringle Best 100 SF
Pringle Modern Fantasy
SF: 101 Best 1985-2010
Fantasy 100
ISFDB Top 100
Horror 100
Nightmare Magazine 100
HWA Reading List
Locus Best SF
200 Significant SF Books by Women
David Brin's YA List
Baen Military SF List
Defining SF Books:
50s | 60s | 70s | 80s | 90s
SF by Women Writers
A Crash Course in the History of Black Science Fiction
Authors
Top Authors
All Authors
All Women Authors
Author Videos
AUTHOR AWARDS
Damon Knight Memorial
World Horror Convention
WFA Life Achievement
Cordwainer Smith Rediscovery
AUTHOR LISTS
Starmont Reader's Guide
Publishers
Top Publishers
All Publishers
PUBLISHER LISTS
Ace Doubles Series:
D | F | G | H | M | #
Conversation Pieces
Classic Library of SF
Critical Explorations in SF&F
EP Masterpieces of SF
Fantasy Masterworks
SF Masterworks
Laser Books
Liverpool SF Texts and Studies
Author's Choice Monthly
Pulphouse Short Stories
Winston SF
Resources
Podcasts
BookTubers
Magazines
Conventions
eBooks
Bookstores
SF/F/H Sub-Genres
Websites
Clubs & Groups
WWEnd
BookTrackr™
The Responsible Parties
WWEnd Patrons
Support WWEnd
Advertise on WWEnd
FAQ
Contact Us
My World
Sign Up now and enjoy the enhanced features only available to members.
Blog
2024 British Fantasy Awards Winners
2024 British Fantasy Awards Shortlists Announced
2023 Nommo Awards Winners
2024 World Fantasy Award Finalists
2024 Aurora Award Winner
Forums
Home | © 2024 Tres Barbas, LLC. All rights reserved.
(Delete all cookies set by this site) | |