|
|
Regular
Posts: 96
Location: Cheshire, England | Part of the WoGF is to write a review. OK, so you don't actually have to do so but it helps the site readership overall if people review the books they've read and it's always handy to have a carrot dangling infront of you in the shape of a prize. If you're like me, though, you don't review books. I've never put a review on Amazon (which is where I buy most of my books) and have so far just put my thoughts as "reviews" on this site. What would you consider to be a "good" review? |
|
| |
|
Uber User
Posts: 794
| Good question. |
|
| |
|
New User
Posts: 1
| Personally, I appreciate a combination of humor/creativity (WWEnd has a really awesome Night Circus review in which the reviewer sort of has a conversation with themselves and I thought it was hilarious) and thoughtful commentary. If a reviewer likes or dislike something, it's helpful to know why so I can figure out if that reasoning applies to me as well.
Edited by mego42 2013-06-19 9:00 AM
|
|
| |
|
Uber User
Posts: 369
Location: Middle TN, USA | I like to read reviews that don't try to take themselves too seriously, unless they are discussing serious matters. I also prefer reviews that talk more about the readers impressions and thoughts about the novel and less of a drawn out rehash of the plot. The only exception to that rule would be if there are extreme scenes which could be considered disturbing ie. graphic rape or torture. I don't mean you have to give away a plot point like "person "A" raped person "B" on pages 187-189" but I would prefer to know that there is graphic rape or extreme violence in the book. I have to steal myself to read those types of novels, and I don't like to come upon them unaware. To this day I am still unable to read any new Stephen King, since I read "Under The Dome"
The best thing to tell someone who is nervous about reviewing books is there are no wrong opinions on reviews, because they are your thoughts on a book you read; Influenced by your own experiences. So just start writing. |
|
| |
|
Regular
Posts: 96
Location: Cheshire, England | So to summarise so far: not too much plot (though note if there are potentially disturbing scenes), make sure you explain why you like/dislike something, keep it creative and don't be too serious. Does length matter? |
|
| |
|
Uber User
Posts: 369
Location: Middle TN, USA | I don't think length matters, as long as you feel you have said what you wanted to about the book. That said, try to stay away from being to "rambley" . (This is one of my biggest problems!) One of the most best reviews I ever read was only 20 words long. They just have to be the right 20 words.  |
|
| |
What makes a good review?